For a very
long time, I loathed the word “motivation.” Early on in my K-12 education, I
noticed the things that drove my peers, such as praise and rewards, and talk of
long-term importance, did not move my needle even a millimeter. Many of my
interests growing up did not align with other kids' my age, so even when the
teacher tried to tap into our interests to get us going, it still fell flat for
me. I truly thought my motivation “system” was simply wrong or broken.
In
elementary school, I would often bring home report cards with good grades,
though not straight As. My dad would encourage me to apply myself more because
he believed I could do it. Although very well-intentioned, I registered this as
external pressure; an expectation that felt like a threat to my autonomy. I
vehemently rejected it, and actively made the choice to not apply myself
further.
It wasn’t
until grade 7 when I realized that, aside from fear of failure, I'm primarily
motivated by genuine curiosity rather than logic, importance, or external
rewards. It wasn’t until university that I experienced the feeling of being
relentlessly motivated to master what I was learning because I genuinely loved
the subject matter.
My experience
with motivation in the early years of education makes a compelling case for the
importance of acknowledging diversity in motivation within the classroom.
Schools put great emphasis on differentiating instruction for students of
differing abilities and developmental readiness, while motivation is often
treated as one-size-fits-all. However, the importance of diversity in
motivation is on par with differences in prior knowledge, developmental
readiness, and ability (Seifert & Sutton, 2017). It’s essential that this
diversity is acknowledged because as Seifert & Sutton (2017) emphasize, a
student being in their seat and seemingly paying attention does not mean they
are motivated to learn, or that they are learning at all. In using a
one-size-fits-all approach, students who don’t respond to typical incentives
and disengage from their work may internalize the idea that they are lazy or
simply a bad student, when that isn’t the case at all; they just aren’t being
given the right fuel.
As future
educators, if we wish to truly motivate our students, we have to drop the
one-size-fits-all approach. Behaviourism still has its place in the classroom,
but it cannot be the only approach. In recognizing that no student is motivated
in the exact same way, we can use a variety of strategies to reach all of our
students, such as providing elements of choice for projects (i.e., format),
encouraging active discussion, providing students with relevant, real-world
tasks connected to their interests, and giving them personalized, highly
informational feedback that can help direct them in their learning. When we
stop using behaviourism as a wide-cast net and acknowledge diversity in
motivation, students can discover what truly motivates them, ultimately helping
in building the foundation for them to become inspired, lifelong
learners.
JennaM@OTU
Sources
Seifert, K., & Sutton, R. (2017). Motivation in Educational Psychology: Barbara Fuller’s Case Study and Theories. In Educational Psychology (p. Chapter 6 (from Educational Psychology)). https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/31779972/Educational%20Psychology.pdf











