I enjoyed learning about confidence and the importance of building this skill within students in the workshop a couple weeks ago, and have since been reflecting on activities within my own K-12 experience that helps build my own. As demonstrated in class, via having two peers ‘argue’ a point, I think learning proper debating techniques, persuasive argumentation, as well as critical analysis are all activities that inherently can hone confidence in students. In all these examples, students would have an opportunity to present an argument and defend their point – and in all of these cases, there would be no one ‘correct answer’, giving students freedom to be creative.
Essay-writing in particular was actually very effective to build my own confidence; I think this is because it involved finding evidence to support my claims - which were sometimes claims I disagreed with - and then having to prove and persuasively argue them. Being able to distill broad ideas into a singular thesis increased my belief in my own competency, and being able to defend it with multiple pieces of evidence, filled me with a sense of confidence in what I was trying to say. The same sentiment extended to when we had debate units in class; if anything, debating filled me with a greater sense of confidence by requiring me to argue with the rest of the class as my audience. While at times terrifying, being pushed into a slightly uncomfortable place while still being provided support, can allow for growth and achievement beyond what was previously thought to be possible. Growth rarely comes from a place of comfort - in fact, some amount of discomfort is needed for optimal growth.
At the same time, it is important to keep in mind that classrooms are full of diverse learners who may have different strengths and different ways in which their confidence can be built. Especially since while discomfort can lead to growth, it is critical not to tip the scales too far in one direction that would lead to severe anxiety or paralysis in students. This is why having a wide variety of activities is important in a classroom. By addressing the different pre-existing competencies of students, teachers can help increase students’ belief in their own capabilities. Furthermore, activities can hone students’ confidence by giving them autonomy and the ability to explore. Feedback and mindset are also important for developing confidence, and designing activities with this goal in mind can be an effective way to foster it.
GarggieT@OTU
